Will-Yums Bake Shop

will yums bake shop logo

About Will-Yums Bake Shop

Sawyer Williams started Will-Yums Bake Shop in 2012, when he was 15 years old. Sawyer graduated from New Bremen High School and went on to earn his associate’s degree in technical studies from Wright State University. Sawyer is now running Will-Yums Bake Shop through New Bremen Coffee Co. where he continues to grow and expand on his passion for baking.

Regular Flavors

1 dozen minimum order | Pricing: $12.00/dozen



Cinnamon cupcake with cinnamon buttercream topped with cinnamon & sugar dusting


Cookies & Cream

Chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream topped with crushed Oreos


Chocolate Peanut Butter Blast

Chocolate cupcake with peanut butter buttercream topped with crushed Reese’s, drizzled with chocolate and peanut butter sauce



Chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream, drizzled with chocolate and marshmallow sauce & topped with crushed graham crackers


Classic Chocolate Cupcake

With chocolate, vanilla or peanut butter buttercream


Classic Vanilla Cupcake

With vanilla or chocolate buttercream

Specialty Flavors

1 dozen minimum order | Pricing: $15.00/dozen

*Seasonal and prices subject to change



Chocolate cupcake filled with caramel sauce & pecans with chocolate buttercream, drizzled caramel & crushed pecans


Banana Cream

Banana cupcake filled with vanilla pudding, banana buttercream and crushed vanilla wafers



Chocolate Cupcake with vanilla buttercream, topped with a dusting of espresso bean & drizzled with chocolate sauce


Black Forest

Chocolate cupcake filled with red tart cherries, topped with chocolate buttercream and cherry jelly


Peanut Butter Hightops

Chocolate cupcake with peanut butter buttercream, topped with chocolate


Peanut Butter Surprise

Peanut butter cupcake filled with crushed Reese’s, with chocolate buttercream and drizzled with peanut butter


Chocolate Extreme

Chocolate cupcake with chocolate buttercream, topped with chocolate jimmies, Hershey bar pieces & drizzled chocolate sauce


Cookie Dough

Chocolate cupcake with cookie dough buttercream, topped with miniature chocolate chips


*Raspberry Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake filled with a fresh raspberry and raspberry puree, with raspberry buttercream and topped with raspberry sauce


*Lemon Cupcake

Lemon cupcake with lemon buttercream, topped with a fresh lemon wedge


*Strawberry Cupcake

Strawberry cupcake with strawberry buttercream, topped with a fresh strawberry


*Strawberry Lemonade

Strawberry cupcake with lemon buttercream, topped with a drinking straw & a fresh lemon wedge


Thin Mint

Chocolate Cupcake with Chocolate Ganache with Mint Buttercream topped with Topp’s Homemade Thin Mint Candy.

6 inch Cakes

2 Layer: $25.00

3 Layer: $30.00

Variety Box

2 dozen for $30.00

Choose any four flavors on the menu, and receive six of each. Minimum of 2 dozen. For every added dozen variety of cupcakes, it will be $15.00 extra.

Marshmallow Flowers


Vanilla or chocolate cake topped with sugar-dipped marshmallows (in your choice of color)

Display Stand Rental


  • Please give us details about your event (date, approximate dozen).
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contact Will-Yums Bake Shop

We do not take online orders. However, if you have an order in mind for an upcoming event, please use the contact form to send us the details and we will be in touch!